Just a thought on this elected positions thing – wondering if anybody here knows. In the US they have lots and lots of elected posts – chief of police, prosecutor, coroner etc. (probably lots of others as well, but those are the ones I can think of from the books I read). Do people standing for these posts in the US stand on a party ticket, or are they actually mostly people with some experience of the role and canvassing on that basis with no party affiliation?
Because it seems that if done properly elected officials may not be a bad thing (I’m still not convinced by the principle, but that’s another matter) if they are actually people who know something about the job. What seems to have happened with these PCCs is that politicians have stood on a party ticket and been voted in along traditional party lines. Personally I couldn’t care less what the party affiliation of somebody doing such a job is, I just want them to do a good one and see no benefit at all to such elections being run on party lines. It’s different when electing to government or your local council where you need to know what group somebody is going to align with (though in the latter case at least I think they’d be far better run by everybody working together rather than fighting each other).
Admittedly our local PCC who I voted for is an independent with experience of the police and he’s turned out as shit and corrupt as the rest of them.