I have ancient mallets on my big bike that appear indestructable
the 2ng gen mallets i`ve on my HT also seem ok after a year of neglect but ridden 4 times a week in all weathers.
i did have a candy pedal fail once but then it was old and second hand.
they have a bad rep but i`m doing OK.
I really like the float – as said above its not flats but you can move yer feet. it was a bit wierd initially as yer feet are a bit wobbly when sat down pedalling but once used to it its great. standign they feel like a flat.
the wider axle q factor in the mallet DH pedals is a great thing. i like the narrower normal axle but i’ve had a few moments where i’ve tried to unclip and the shoe fouls on teh crank. this doesnt happen for me with teh wider axle. also the wider stance give more control which is good for the big bike.
using candys i had some accidental release when the cleats got worn (i think because the pedal isnt as grippy and when landing a jump or in a compression the foot can move easier – i think they do pedal spacers to help reduce this but i didnt know at teh time!) but with teh mallets this has never happened and i get a suprisingly long time out of cleats.
i curently use spec 2f0 shoes. i`ve used vans clips and some random disco slippers too.