Well I’ve had one for 4 months. I love it. Actually loved it. You will probably be aware of the 2009 manufacturing problems but I took a gamble on an 09 – brand new old stock from an LBS (4 months ago for me) for less than half price (880 with rp2/reba etc).
I say gamble ’cause 09s are notorious for cracking / splitting and the warranty backup wasnt great – and downright atrocious if you bought from Merlin. 2010 onwards are fine by all accounts. There were 2 problems with 09 models- the asymetric swingarm (led to cracks on the DS) and the top tube / downtube weld.
When it cracked my lbs werent exactly surprised.They saw it all before. To be fair the warranty backup now is reasonable – if a bit slow. I’m currently waiting for a warranty ’12 model. No quibbles / hassle. Just not available for a few weeks.
Overall – its a great trail design. 3.3 kg frame weight (inc shock). Sizing is a tad on the large side of normal. Pedalling is like a hardtail – but it tracks bumps / steps etc perfectly. I’m far too much of a wimp to push it to the limits on the downs. Overall – to be honest I dont have a whole lot to compare it to = but I am seriously missing it at mo.
It is a genuinly great climber. And great for long days out. As I said I dont have a whole lot of FS stuff to compare to but after 5-6 hours on a super my ass (old!) is an awful lot happier!
The 09’s came with a 100 Reba, the 10/11 with a 120. Same frame geom (different factory). I’d my 09 with 120 and it was fine.
Just to re-iterate: the 2010/11 are (apparently) fine reliability wise. I personally would not buy one with an asymettric (on 09 and some ’10 models) swing arm unless from an lbs you trust.