Personally: didn’t like it.
* when the seat is low, if you pick the bike up by the back of the saddle, the seatpost just rises up (and then lowers again when you push it down).
(The gravity dropper apparently doesn’t do this, saw somebody with one at CyB and it clicks in at the lower position).
* The very slight amount of play when it’s up bugs me. I’ve seen an advert for one with a ‘patented one way bearing’ that supposedly gets rid of this problem, but how well it does I don’t know.
* I didn’t have it long enough for maintenance to be an issue, but i quite enjoy maintenance so stripping and regreasing wouldn’t have been a problem, but might be for some.
* but the main issue with it, and this might sound silly – but, the fact that the feature is there just tempts you to use it, whereas before you wouldn’t have needed to bother. i.e., for a short climb you might put it up, whereas if you didn’t have it you would just honk up it standing up.
On flat-ish bits i found i spent too long faffing about with it trying to find the ‘optimium’ height.
so I got rid of it.