Does bombing Gaddaffis compound count as protecting civilians?
depends if his command and control bunker is in there I suppose
Sending in military advisors – clear breach. Arming the rebels. Not stopping the rebels when they killcivilians.
but it’s not that easy is it. You could make a good argument that the proper training of the rebels would significantly reduce civilian casaulties as the “beruit unload” tactics employed by the rebels in built up areas must be causing significant numbers.
the deployment of communications specialists would enable aid to be sent to the right places
the deployment of fire control teams would stop the indiscriminate use of direct and indirect large calibre weapons
etc etc
if they hadn’t gone in they would have had Gadafi clearing towns house by house all on 24 hour rolling news
I think the UK government was pushed into this because we are one of the few countries with “deployable” forces. Because they were pushed the “moment” was lost. Once they took the first step they were locked in to the long drawn out mess have now
I don’t think there is a right answer to this, any path would have had intended and unintended consequences.
It’s a shame there isn’t any real debate about the issues and ideas on proper courses of action for what next, instead we have people picking on a phrase to justify “what they already knew” in a vacuous point scoring exercise. The air time given to this should have been given to debate about the strategic options and how to get to a sustainable future for Libya, or is that too hard?