used to stay here http://www.badrallach.com/stay/bothy.html
a bit sanitised I know, but it has to do for a range of people, however having been there 4 yrs on the trot we are looking for somewhere similar. NW of Scotland or Islands prefered but within reach of Central Scotland.
Cheap - dont need/want TV, dishwasher, spa bath etc
Mountains for walking
Water - loch or sea bit of fishin
Trails for riding
Isolated enough that 8-10 pissed 40 somethings on weekend passes won't upset people by shouting **** at each other at 1 am!
Maybe a pub in walking distance...
Moon on stick would help too