Viewing 40 posts - 1 through 40 (of 49 total)
  • Badgers…
  • zokes
    Free Member

    Or soon to be lack thereof:

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-23845851

    Ineffectual pandering to the shire Tory vote, or does this actually have any scientific credibility?

    fourbanger
    Free Member

    We’ll find out when they’ve got rid of some.

    core
    Full Member

    The badger debate really is getting boring now, they should not be protected and need controlling, all species without predators get out of control, and for me, there is enough evidence to at least trial culling, though I accept it may not be THE answer in the long term, it needs to be tried, as there really aren’t any viable alternatives at the moment.

    Vaccinating badgers would be futile, and frankly a huge waste of resources & time, as you cannot guarantee to reach a high enough percentage of the population.

    The compensation being paid out to farmers for TB infected cattle is millions, and increasing, so the situation needs sorting.

    The long term, and best solution is cattle vaccination, but that is some years off as a synthetic vaccine that doesn’t use the live virus is required in order to maintain exports. Current vaccines use a live virus component which tests can’t differentiate from the actual virus. If we were to use that it would kill the export market overnight.

    yes badgers are cute and cuddly & nice to see to the general population, and they don’t appear to do any harm, but the truth is their numbers are spiralling out of control & they are the most likely carrier of TB.

    It may not be ideal, but I don’t see any better alternative to a trial cull, at least in the short – medium term.

    Have lost all respect for (Dr) Brian May by the way, what a twonk.

    MrWoppit
    Free Member

    Presumably the protestors, who seem to think that the natural world is a sort of Beatrix Potter fantasyland, aren’t worried about the imminent loss of the British hedgehog due to predation by an out-of-control badger population…

    zokes
    Free Member

    & they are the most likely carrier of TB.

    Apart from cattle, that is

    It may not be ideal, but I don’t see any better alternative to a trial cull, at least in the short – medium term.

    That’s fine, but is there any scientific precedent to suggest that it will be successful? My understanding of this is that it is just as likely to spread the disease due to badgers fleeing the area to other, non-infected areas.

    Presumably the protestors, who seem to think that the natural world is a sort of Beatrix Potter fantasyland, aren’t worried about the imminent loss of the British hedgehog due to predation by an out-of-control badger population…

    If the trial was designed to reduce numbers to assist in population dynamics, as opposed to eradicate a virus for profit, you’d have a point.

    Northwind
    Full Member

    What was proven to reduce bovine TB spread was reducing bovine spread- foot and mouth travel restrictions caused a massive drop. Cows pass it to cows, and we mingle our herds a lot. Meanwhile evidence for a badger cull is at best shaky and sometimes indicates that it’ll increase the spread of TB.

    I’m not going to come over all “badgerz is cute” because I like steak more than I like badgers, but to me it seems pretty obvious that the science is bad and that it’s being done because the one thing that definitely will work is unpalatable.

    kayak23
    Full Member

    all species without predators get out of control

    MrWoppit
    Free Member

    If the trial was designed to reduce numbers to assist in population dynamics, as opposed to eradicate a virus for profit, y

    Sound of a hair splitting. Win/win, if you ask me.

    Farmers with “closed” herds still wind up getting BTV in their cattle. Where DOES it come from, I wonder (rhetoric alert)?

    Next thing you know, they’ll be whining about the return of hunting foxes with hounds.

    Pfft.

    fasthaggis
    Full Member

    I’m not going to come over all “badgerz is cute” because I like steak more than I like badgers

    🙂

    zokes
    Free Member

    Sound of a hair splitting.

    Not at all. The methods and experimental design to test the effects of reducing a (in British terms) large omnivore on the population dynamics of other mammals and the wider food web are quite different that those used to assess whether eradication of badgers = eradication of a virus.

    If the money spent on this farce was spent on research for a vaccine, we might get somewhere.

    Clover
    Full Member

    The science says that culling increases TB initially as badger populations shift.

    It also says that the cull will have an impact in 9 years, bringing about a 16% reduction.

    It’s not exactly a panacea.

    Although vaccination sounds like a more intensive approach it doesn’t have the initial increase effect and will bring down the number of badgers able to catch and transmit TB.

    I like the work the Wildlife Trusts are doing - if you’re bothered.

    I keep sheep and have huge sympathy for farmers seeing their herds destroyed, but I can’t see that the cull will help.

    wwaswas
    Full Member

    youtube won’t link, but this is worth a look “Run for your lives!”

    https://myspace.com/elwellinnit/video/trigger-happy-tv/5741873

    chewkw
    Free Member

    I see not much wildlife on the island in future …

    nickc
    Full Member

    If the trial was designed to reduce numbers to assist in population dynamics, as opposed to eradicate a virus for profit, you’d have a point.

    It’s my understanding that this trail is to determine how effective shooting is as a method of control rather than effecting the outcome of further infections of TB

    yunki
    Free Member

    You used to see a fair few badgers around Devon, they were a regular sight.. I haven’t seen any at all, not one, not even roadkill in the last 5 years..

    numbers spiralling out of control my big fat hairy arse

    zokes
    Free Member

    It’s my understanding that this trail is to determine how effective shooting is as a method of control rather than effecting the outcome of further infections of TB

    Well, in that case, I can save them the bother.

    In terms of controlling an individual badger, it’s probably highly effective. In terms of controlling a badger population at the regional scale, it’s probably highly ineffective.

    thegreatape
    Free Member

    yes badgers are cute and cuddly…and they don’t appear to do any harm

    I beg to differ

    zokes
    Free Member
    Clover
    Full Member

    There have already been culls – articles like this by researchers who have already tried culling.

    Culling is a ‘we have to do something no matter how rubbish it is’ response. It won’t work very well overall, it’ll make things worse in the short term.

    Dales_rider
    Free Member

    What about beavers ? can you catch TB from them ?

    gearfreak
    Free Member

    Evidence from New Zealand would indicate that control of external Virus Vectors (in the UK’s case, Badgers) does have an effect on control of the virus.

    http://www.bovinetb.info/newzealand.php

    wwaswas
    Full Member

    Bernard Hinault is probably worried, what with the Tour coming to the UK next year.

    yunki
    Free Member

    Dales_rider – Member
    What about beavers ? can you catch TB from them ?

    Beaver spotted in the Otter

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    yes badgers are cute and cuddly

    I dare you to try, if so can you record it?

    Its estimated by DEFRA scientists to reduce the spread of TB by what 15% or something. It is at best pissing in the wind and massive waste of time and money. Its a political stunt at the expense of wild life.

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    that NZ article is odd as if you go to NZ you cannot **** move for possums

    Pigface
    Free Member

    I think the whole Badger cull thing is a bit weak minded and not likely to cure the problem, Badgers arent the only carriers out there, as has been said other cattle, deer, muntjacks all sorts.

    The culling thing was tried in Ireland and apparently was sucsessful.

    MrSparkle
    Full Member

    So, to summarise:
    It’s not likely to cure the problem but when they did it in Ireland it was succesful.
    Okaaaaayyy then…

    Pigface
    Free Member

    “apparently” Mr Sparkle as well as everyone else who has commented on this I am no expert 😀

    I think they were judging success by the fall in new cases, stats can be manipulated to show anything.

    teamhurtmore
    Free Member

    There are four dead badgers within 2 miles of my house at the moment (road kill) and that’s without looking for fhen. Can’t recall seeing them alive in the wild when I was young or even much road kill. But regular sightings on lanes and main roads all around Surrey these days.

    unovolo
    Free Member

    I’ve seen 2 dead ones on the roads near us in the last week so us motorists seem to be doing a pretty good job of culling them anyway.

    Stopped by a dead one yesterday as my daughter had never seen one in real life,(yes another fun day with dad looking at roadkill)

    johnellison
    Free Member

    Why can’t farmers vaccinate their cattle? Oh yeah, silly me – because it would cost cash money… 🙄

    wwaswas
    Full Member

    Bunnyhop
    Full Member

    there should be a grey squirrel cull – tree rats.

    zokes
    Free Member

    there should be a grey squirrel Tory cull – tree rats.

    http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2012/oct/13/badger-cull-mindless

    However, the scientists reject the idea of scientific support for the cull, which could wipe out 100,000 badgers, a third of the national population. The cull policy is “mindless”, according to Lord John Krebs, one of the UK’s most eminent scientists and the architect of the landmark 10-year culling trials that ended in 2007. “The scientific case is as clear as it can be: this cull is not the answer to TB in cattle. The government is cherry-picking bits of data to support its case.”

    I met the guy about seven years ago. He knows his stuff. The morons in government do not, and their own chief scientist backs Krebs’ assertion

    mt
    Free Member

    Why can’t farmers vaccinate their cattle? Oh yeah, silly me – because it would cost cash money…

    No because it would be illegal under EU and UK law to sell the milk or meat. The TB vaccine at the moment uses a live virus. This cannot be allowed into the food chain. Work is being done on alternatives but its some way of. Perhaps you’d have a different view if a little fury animal was going to put you out of a job. As far as I’m aware bovine TB can effect humans I’d like to see a lid kept on it’s spread.

    Given the apparent over population of badgers that these cull trials are suposed to be putting to the test, I’d also like the way modern dairy herds are kept to be tested. Are some of these herds “over populated” and kept confined (wintered indoors) for to long. I suspect (but don’t know) that intensive farming has not helped the larger herds. We all need our cheap food though.

    Given the commercial issues, the cuddly animal issues I’d say the government are handling it resonably well.

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    Given the commercial issues, tory voting famrers and the labour voting conservationists the cuddly animal issues I’d say the government are handling it resonably very well.

    just a shame about the lack of scientific rigor

    zokes
    Free Member

    If the Tories are our economic saviours, why are they ignoring 50m-worth of government funded research?

    As far as I’m aware bovine TB can effect humans I’d like to see a lid kept on it’s spread.

    I think you’ll find the scar on the top of your arm that you received when you were about 14 is pretty effective at that.

    billyboulders
    Free Member

    Excuse my ignorance, I have done zero research. Why can’t they vaccinate the cows?

    tazzymtb
    Full Member

    Zokes you do know that a bcg is only about 80% effective and only lasts 15-20 years don’t you. Plus the increase in resistant strains of tb meam that it may well be on the increase again

    irc
    Full Member

    Excuse my ignorance, I have done zero research. Why can’t they vaccinate the cows?

    From page 1 of this thread ….

    Current vaccines use a live virus component which tests can’t differentiate from the actual virus. If we were to use that it would kill the export market overnight.

Viewing 40 posts - 1 through 40 (of 49 total)

The topic ‘Badgers…’ is closed to new replies.