Apologies for what I suspect is a somewhat tired subject, but I wondered if I could engage the hive mind on the marvellous subject of 1×11 chainlines!
I recently got back into mountain biking after about 15 years off and bought by first full suspension bike. Its lovely (new Boardman FS Pro). However, it has a 1×11 drivetrain which has the classic “pedal back and the chain drops down the cassette” problem. Not a massive issue, but the way the bike is setup makes me think its fixable. Here are the facts I have gleaned as a novice so far:
– it’s a SRAM GX derailleur and cassette (10-42)
– it’s a FSA single ring comet crankset (32t) and threaded BB, 73mm
– The chainline appears straight somewhere around the 8th gear (i.e. 4th smallest)
– therefore the chain looks pretty crazy when in first (42 cog), but it works
– if I backpedal at all in first, it changes gear. This is a pain on hard ascents, just setting the pedals in position causes it to drop down, meaning a gear change as soon as you start off
– there is a single ~3mm spacer on the drive side of the BB
– I measured the chainline to be ~52mm
So, given the above it appears to my novice eyes that
– the chainline would be better around 49mm
– I have heard mention of changing the BB spacer to the non-drive side. But I have also heard caution as that can cause issues with thread depth on the BB cup.
– I *think* a SRAM GX crankset and BB would result in a 49mm chainline.
So I have a few specific questions:
1. What *should* the chainline be for 1×11?
2. If it should be 49mm, but is setup as 52mm have Boardman messed up here, or am I misunderstanding something?
3. Can I change the spacer to the other side to fix it?
4. Or do I need replace the BB etc? (or just ignore it for now)
I did ask in Halfords about this, and was told it was just a feature of 1×11, but I felt I was being fobbed off tbh.
Any help much appreciated.