I’ve had a couple of Nicolai’s with this feature.
On the helius ST I noticed that on the longest travel option, as mentioned above, the damping was insufficient, and it also meant running very high shock pressure, which ultimately made it unpleasent to ride; On the short travel setting the compression damping was far too hugh, and again the ride suffered a a result.
I worked out that on the low travel setting it had a leverage ratio of about 2.2:1, whereas on the long travel it was a bit over 3:1. For one shock, this is too much to cope with. I spoke to TF tuned about this and they felt that in the short travel mode the Dhx just couldn’t flow enough oil. In the end I settled on the next to longest travel and it worked fine.
I think that Scott also designed the Gamble to run different length shocks, but my problem with this approach is that it starts to get as expensive as buying two different or more specific frames.
I’ve ended up having two seperate bikes, as it became frustrating to try to make do with a jack of all trades: too heavy and slack for most riding, built with too light kit for big mountains and DH.