I saw two 3D sets in action yesterday, both Sony. I was not impressed!
First off, both sets produced a very noticeable flickering effect, especially when wearing the supplied polarizing glasses.
One set was showing psuedo/simulated 3d of a live footy broadcast. It just looked a bit fuzzy and the 3D element was barely noticeable – FAIL!.
I then saw the other set which was playing a BlueRay disc. The depth of field was there, but the margins of characters in the foreground were out of focus. This is £1500 technology and £500 sets blow it away – FAIL!
Then I looked at a standard HD TV in all it’s pin sharp glory and wondered why anyone would bother blowing a huge pile of money on such a gimmick as 3D. And who’d want to wear numpty goggles to watch TV?
I’m absolutely convinced it won’t catch on!
3D TV – FAIL!
Aside from that, LCD TV still can’t handle motion (HD or SD). You get a fuzzy mess until the display goes static – FAIL.
Plasma sets faired a lot better, but weren’t perfect.
I looked at a wide range of sets and found the cheapest one viewed from a realistic distance was no worse than the most expensive.
These thin LED sets offer low power consumption and better aesthetics, but the sound they produce is nasty and these sets are expensive – FAIL.
Pursuing HD video has clearly become subject to “The Emperor’s New Clothes” effect!
If you are buying a new flat panel TV, go for the cheapest 1080p set and look for one which has the distinctly low res internet TV capability.