Overview Chat Bike Members News Women
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • 17. 5 or 19?
  • sevenandnine
    Full Member

    Hi there,

    Sorry if this is a neewbie question or has been asked before.

    I am 178 cm tall and am looking to buy a 2012 Core 26.5

    The bike shop has two sizes available, 19″ for people 178 cm and taller, and a 17.5″ frame for people up to 178cm tall.

    Is is better to have a smaller frame for more manoveribilty on the trails?

    Any opinions or advice would be great, I think an inch and a half would make a difference…
    thanks 🙂

    Posted 11 years ago
    tinribz
    Free Member

    17.5 sounds spot on IMHO.

    Posted 11 years ago
    daveh
    Free Member

    Try both but assuming thats not possible, smaller is usually better especially if you value your soft bits. My last 2 bikes have been 18inch and I’m 185cm.

    Posted 11 years ago
    LMT
    Free Member

    Need to sit on the bike, and see how it feels, reach standover etc ethier or both might not quite fit.

    Posted 11 years ago
    mboy
    Free Member

    It’s the Top Tube length that’s most important to be honest, and there’s only 15mm in them. Also depends on your proportions…

    Anyway… I’m 1m80 and ride a 17.5″ Genesis Altitude. I went for the 17.5 over the 19 cos I’ve got slightly longer legs and a shorter torso but also cos I prefer a slightly smaller bike with a longer stem. I could happily ride a 19 though with a shorter stem, but I prefer the handling of the smaller frame.

    Posted 11 years ago
    Mackem
    Full Member

    It’s a hard one. The 19″ probably lends itself better to a short stem, which may be better for you.
    But then, it depends on the frame, the toptube might be long enough for you to have a short stem anyway.

    FWIW I stepped down from a 19″ with a 50mm stem to a 17.5″ and after much experimentation I’m running a 80mm stem on it and it feels perfect.

    Best to try if you can.

    Posted 11 years ago
    smell_it
    Free Member

    What do you ride now? And how does it fit you?

    Posted 11 years ago
    sevenandnine
    Full Member

    Thanks everyone

    Posted 11 years ago
    Kahurangi
    Full Member

    You might be happier with the larger frame and a slightly shorter stem…

    basically what Mackem said.

    Posted 11 years ago
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)

The topic ‘17. 5 or 19?’ is closed to new replies.

Overview Chat Bike Members News Women